I should warn you all that though I didn’t get any major
spoilers about the storylines, the interviews contain some minor
“spoilerly” answers and certain hints about the upcoming
Season 6. So, if anyone reading this is a hard-core unspoiled fan,
you might skip certain answers, but don’t skip the entire
interviews because all three women I talked too are very fascinating
professionals and individuals with a lot of great insights about
the show and the life outside of it.
Rose Troche came in next. Rose is a director, writer, and a producer
for the show, and she’s handling her multiple roles very well.
I’ve never talked to her before, but I always admired her
as a director. Rose directed and wrote so many great episodes, including
the “Pilot”, “Let’s Do it”, “Lawfully”
(writer), “Luck, Next Time”, and “Looking Back”
from Season One; “Loneliest Number”, “Labyrinth”
(writer), “Loud and Proud” from Season 2; and let’s
not forget the sizzling “Liquid Heat” episode in Season
Five. Do you see the pattern? Most of these episodes are Bette and
Tina oriented and we talked a little about it.
B&TF: Rose, maybe you can introduce yourself…
RT: I am Rose Troche. I write, direct, and co-executive
produce.
B&TF: How many episodes will you be directing in Season 6?
RT: Three. Three of the last eight.
B&TF: Actually, most of the episodes that you’ve directed,
people always praise them a lot. One of the reasons, I think, is
because they are sort of Bette and Tina oriented.
RT: Oh yeah! It’s very funny that I end up a lot
with Bette and Tina. As a matter of fact, the episode that I’m
directing next is a big, big, big Bette & Tina episode.
B&TF: Can you tell me more about it?
RT: (laughing) No, I can’t but that was good…nice
try! I think there are people I like to write for as well, so I
think I definitely like to write Bette angry. I got to write a couple
of things for her where she goes off (laughing).
B&TF: So you directed the episode 509 with the blackout and
the elevator scene. Tell me a little about how you came up with
this idea of making a sequence when everybody is having sex at the
same time.
RT: Well, Ilene Chaiken wrote the script, I came in to
direct; and that’s usually what happens and what the process
is. We have our first drafts, they’re not first drafts like
normal first drafts; they’re actually the result of quite
a bit of work. We have the first draft that we publish here, which
is probably the result of like three or four drafts prior to that.
And then they sort of get tweaked and changed, and we decided to
do it as everybody having sex at the same time at the end of the
thing because the sex was kind of spread throughout the episode,
different places, different times. We decided to sort of have it
be all just simultaneous action. And that was really interesting
because I’ve done a lot, a lot of sex scenes on this show,
as you can imagine over the years (laughing).
B&TF: Some of them were really brilliant.
RT: Oh, thank you. I don’t know if they were mine
(laughing) but thank you.
B&TF: Well, as a fan of Bette and Tina, I can say that their
scenes were brilliant so if you have done any of them…
RT: Yes, I did.
B&TF: Thank you for that.
RT: Welcome (laughing). Yeah, it was just a hot sweaty
episode and I think what was really interesting about that is that
I sort of dove into my bag of tricks – because I was like,
“How am I going to do seven different sex scenes in one episode?
Oh my god. Should I have seven different ways of doing sex in the
episodes or something else…what am I going do?” So,
basically I just settled on everyone going down on each other (laughing).
So it became a scene where people were having sex in kind of the
same way, which actually ended up being kind of a real thing for
the show because some of the actors who had done sex scenes, had
never done that on the show before, so it was really interesting
for them to ‘act’ that part. So, it was kind of funny.
B&TF: Did you film each of the scenes at different times and
then just edit them in together later?
RT: Oh yeah, yeah, yeah; different days, different times.
B&TF: Because it seemed like some of the scenes were maybe
one minute long but how long does it actually take to film scenes
like that?
RT: It’s different for each scene. You know when
we did the Jenny and Nikki having sex and the crane comes over the
log on the set and it comes down and it comes back… that’s
pretty much was done in real time, there’s just no cuts in
it. So, it takes us the time of rehearsing and then every time we
do a sex scene, I take the actors aside and rehearse them where
we’re going to do the sex scene, or I’ll take them to
a different set and privately go through whatever it is they need
to do… the things I want to have happen in this kind of time…and
they become actually very mechanical. Just for a comfort level,
I can just break it down into steps, like when I say, “One
- put your hand on her breast”. It helps them have a structure
in which to work. I think when I directed the Pilot, I sort of made
the mistake, and it really was a directorial mistake, to allow people
to have a little bit of wine and let the camera run ,and it really
puts it all on the actors to have to figure things out. And that
can get a little awkward, so what I started doing very shortly after
that was very choreographed sex scenes.
B&TF: I also read that the Pilot scene between Bette and Tina
when they start reconnecting – it started out being very short
but the Showtime executives wanted to make it longer.
RT: Yeah, that was a whole discussion about it. I remember
I was on the set shooting that day when I got a phone call from
Gary Levine (executive VP of original programming at Showtime) and
I said, “Well, what exactly do you want? You want a sex scene?”
He was like, “No, no. I don’t want a sex scene.”
And I told him, “You want a sex scene, you want more so you
want a sex scene.” And so, whatever, we argued over semantics.
He said he wanted more of a connection. I’m like, “I
think we have a connection, you want a sex scene” (laughing).
And, we went back and did that sex scene and it’s the one
I’m very, very proud of, it’s the one between Bette
and Tina in the Pilot.
B&TF: Fans are still talking about it.
RT: Yes, I think that’s one of my favorite sex scenes.
And that was the very first time that I counted down to orgasm.
Because they were like, “What do you want, do you want an
orgasm?” So I was like, “Ten, nine, eight…”,
which is very funny because we had to remove my talking, which is
hard because we had to reconstruct breathing, because they’re
actually breathing heavily. And I’m in the background going,
“Five, four…”. But it gave them some directions
because otherwise, they’re not doing it in time. They’re
such professionals that they gave it all. I particularly like working
with the two of them because they really commit. I think Jennifer
and Laurel really commit to being like, “Okay, we are playing
partners in a long term relationship who are now back together and
are trying to commit to a life together. And you know that to commit
to a life together you have to really make an effort to continue
to have sex.” That’s one of the things that lesbians
sometimes don’t (laughing).
B&TF: Yes, I actually asked Ilene to make Bette and Tina having
sex in each episode in season 6. Will my wish be granted?
RT: (loud laughter) I don’t know if once in each
episode (laughing, again).
B&TF: Well, you know, Season 5 everyone was waiting for them
to reconnect and get back together, and in Episode 506, the second
scene between Bette and Tina was sort of reminiscent of the Pilot
sex scene. It was the same exact…
RT: Yes, as a matter of fact, Ilene directed that and I
think that you’d have to ask her but I think her plan was
to redo The Sex scene which, I remember seeing it, is basically
the same shot. I asked about it, and I think that it was really
reminiscent of that very first scene because it was about them really
reconnecting again and that was a really potent love scene and she
wanted to help them back to what that was. It was premeditated,
as far as I know. It was a very premeditated kind of decision on
her part.
B&TF: Some people were saying Ilene was just recycling some
old ideas but when I first saw it I thought of the Pilot right away
and for me it was just wonderful because they were reconnecting
then and they were reconnecting now and it’s not just about
sex anymore.
RT: Right. And I don’t want to speak for Ilene, but
I think that was, from my point of view as the viewer, the familiarity
of when you know someone and you get back together with them. When
you’re with someone for a long time, you pull out your A list
of your favorite sexual moments with that someone. You have a repertoire,
and then you pull from that repertoire to be re-familiar. These
are two people, who’ve had a lot of sex with other people
in the interim, then they come back together and you’ll need
to discuss these things. Sometimes there are all of these new tricks,
like “Now you kiss different, where did that come from? That
must have come from Helena or that came from here and something
doesn’t feel right.” And they were really connecting
in a serious way of getting back together, and I think they pulled
from their repertoire of sort of sexual moves or whatever it is,
of what was good for them. So that’s why I think she made
that. That wasn’t a recycling; it was a very conscious thing.
B&TF: So do you think your personal favorite characters to
write are Bette and Tina?
RT: Oh! I love writing Alice. She’s just wonderful;
her delivery is so funny and just to write comedy is so much fun.
B&TF: Most of the writing – where does it come from.
Everyone contributes or how is it done?
RT: Well, we all write our own scripts and Ilene writes
the majority. Ilene will almost always take a pass on everyone’s
script. She’s the Executive Producer, all the rest of us –
Angela, Elizabeth, and I are all Co-Executive Producers. So, we
don’t really re-write each other’s work, our scripts
go to Ilene, then they go to the network, and they go back to Ilene;
you know that kind of thing.
B&TF: The network also has to approve them?
RT: Absolutely, but they’re very hands-off on this
show. I think it’s a very dreamy job. We were talking the
other night, I was talking to Angela (Robinson) and just saying
that it’s a very funny show, because it doesn’t set
you up at all like for network TV where everyone’s breathing
down your neck. They’re very respectful, and they’ll
give their notes, but they’re never really that huge or severe;
and then we just adjust for their notes. It’s sort of a mutual
respect; they don’t get up in our stuff so much. Ilene handles
that part as well.
B&TF: You know there are some viewers who would analyze every
second of the show and would point out that something is inconsistent,
this is not how it happened in Season 1, etc. So, is it because
you have all these different directors who sometimes don’t
know what happened in the previous season or because of so many
different writers?
RT: No. You know what? In Seasons 1 through 3 we really
did change writers a little bit more, more than we needed to; we
could have settled on the same writers a bit more. I think we thought
we needed to have a male writer on the show, which we really ended
up not having to have, and it took us a while to figure out, to
not feel bad that it was all women, you know what I mean? Because
this show really is all about women. So, I think some of it does
come from different directors. It’s a really great show for
a director to work on. I mean, having worked on other people’s
shows where there’s much more of a firm hand, we do allow
people to bring their vision. We do want that from directors; we
want them to bring in their creativity and really give us their
best. In order to do that, we give them a little bit of latitude,
and I think sometimes that does give us things that are maybe slightly
uneven in tone, occasionally. But I think that it’s gotten
better that way. I mean, I know that there are some super die-hard
fans. And it’s hard because there’s just stuff that
we do want to have happen and because of something that previously
happened, we’re like – “No, we shouldn’t
but…” sometimes we do it.
B&TF: Can you give me an example?
RT: You know, it’s really funny, nothing’s
coming to mind right now. But I think we do have a little bit of
play sometimes with reality.
B&TF: Well, one example, in Season 3 when Alice and Dana were
breaking up in the beginning of one episode it said, “Month
and a half ago” and then next episode starts with the same
scene, they are still breaking up but it said, “Month ago”,
making it look like it took them that long to break up.
RT: Oh, it had to be a joke. That was just a joke as in
– “How long does it take a lesbian to break-up?”
(laughing) Sometimes I think the inconsistency is seen by people
who don’t understand our humor. We’re just trying to
be funny. That’s just making fun of lesbians. It’s like,
“Come on, folks, let’s speed it up.” It should
have been like a year and a month later, still breaking up, then
people would have gotten it.
B&TF: Well, just like in Season 5 when Bette says, “Some
lesbians, you have to break up with them twice...”
RT: Yeah, yeah. It takes a while for it to stick sometimes.
B&TF: So, right now you’re shooting episode 603, right?
RT: Yes, 603. Angela’s shooting 603. I just got done
shooting 602, and I’m shooting the next one.
B&TF: Yes, I will let fans know to watch episode 604 for more
Bette and Tina.
RT: Yeah, yeah.
B&TF: What was the most challenging thing for you working on
The L Word for the past 5-6 years?
RT: The most challenging thing, I think for me, it’s
getting into the LA vibe. I’m an East Coast person. For me
it’s the “LA thing”. I live part time in LA, but
when I’m there, it’s very different; the women are very
different, the lesbians are very different on the East Coast. I
live in New York, so I think it’s always been the biggest
challenge to put myself into a Los Angeles mentality because I’m
so deeply East Coast. We just have a slightly different community
there. It’s a little less fashion forward. It’s a little
less fancy, let’s put it that way (laughing).
B&TF: And what’s been the most rewarding thing?
RT: Oh, I think it’s just been tremendously rewarding
to be on a show during one of the worst administrations in the US
in decades. So, to be working on a show like this and to feel subversive
in such a ridiculously conservative time and at a moment when I
feel like church and state are not separate, that they’re
really just combining.
So, it’s felt good to feel like a rebel. I felt tremendously
proud to be a part of the first show. I feel like, after “Go
Fish” and other things in my career, it feels like something
totally natural to continue to represent the lesbian community in
such a way. And I’m very proud of that.
B&TF: Speaking of “Go Fish”, I talked to Guinevere
Turner at a convention and she mentioned the sequel…
RT: She just wrote me!! I just got an email from her. She
said, “Send me the notes, I feel like working on it. We’ll
see if we can get through it without fighting.”
B&TF: Is it still in writing or in pre-production?
RT: No. It’s not in pre-production at all, are you
kidding? No, no, no, no… We keep on having philosophical differences
on the tone of the film. I don’t want the film to be bitter
and angry, but I think Guin thinks that would be ‘funny’.
If you look at the first “Go Fish”, I think it would
be a disservice to make a “Go Fish Two” that bitter
and angry. It is excruciatingly difficult to watch the first one,
by the way, because I was barely a filmmaker back then. I used weird
angles…it was super clunky. We hadn’t watched it in
eleven years, and we all got together in Paris. It was V.S. (Brody),
who plays Ely in the movie, Guin who plays Max, of course, and who
co-wrote and co-produced it, and myself. V.S. has lived in France
for almost 10 years now. We were sitting in her apartment, and it
was afternoon and we opened up a bottle of wine, and it was like
– “OK, let’s stick it in the DVD player.”
And I was like, “Oh my god, this is excruciating.”
B&TF: You probably needed more than one bottle of wine…
RT: Yes, I think we did go through like two bottles of
wine. By the end, I actually had tears in my eyes. There’s
something so extraordinarily special that cuts through all the awkwardness,
and there’s sincerity there, and I looked up and said, “God,
it’s like fifteen years later and look at us; we’re
like a bunch of old hags now.” And I think we need to tap
into some hope that we may still have. I want it to be a film about
the families that we make and the families we create. And it’s
going to be all the same people who are still in each other’s
lives; just like we are. It really is the real life thing that happens.
We made this movie together and most of us are still very close.
BT: What can you tell to the fans now that the show is going to
be over?
RT: Oh. Don’t worry, fans. It’s never over.
It will live on in some way. You know, they just announced the spin-off
and though we don’t know who it will be…just hold it
together. And, if not that, I think that these things inevitably
work in such a way that we’ll see more. It’s funny but
I think that the lesbian characters are still not out there. You’re
more likely to see the gay male character but the lesbian characters
haven’t permeated television in such a way. We had ER, for
one, and just for one second we have, what is it? Lipstick Jungle?
B&TF: Well, there’s Cashmere Mafia?
RT: Right, Cashmere Mafia but it was cancelled…anyway.
Rose and I ran out of time, but I thanked her for talking with me.
We will all look forward to the sequel to “Go Fish!”
COMMENTS DISCLAIMERS
L-Word.com is not affiliated with Showtime Inc. and no connection is expressed or implied.
2008-09-12, 12:58:59 PM From:mightymouse Comments: Thank you, thank you, B&TF for your dedication and sharing this "meaty" conversation. These photos and smart interviews are like the long-awaited rain in a long, dry, sprack-less summer. Again, muchas gracias! :>
2008-09-14, 22:32:47 PM From:Seahurst Comments: That my friend was a kick ass interview!!